Located in Carmel, Indiana, Moyer Fine Jewelers is proud to offer an immense selection of GIA-certified natural loose diamonds to Indianapolis area customers! As one of the nation’s top jewelry stores, we are proud to offer one of the largest inventories of round brilliant diamonds, radiant diamonds, princess cut diamonds, pear shape diamonds, oval shape diamonds, cushion cut diamonds, and more! Our sales associates make finding your ideal natural loose diamond simple—whether you’re looking to set it into an engagement ring or make a pendant necklace!

Approximately 99% of our loose diamonds are authenticated and graded by leading organizations such as the Gemological Institute of America (GIA). Because of this third-party certificate, our customers can rest assured knowing that theres complete transparency with each and every diamond they see and/or purchase at Moyer.

Every loose diamond at Moyer has passed through the hands of our one diamond buyer, a GIA Graduate Gemologist. Because all of our diamonds are purchased by one person, shes able to apply the same level of scrutiny to each diamond, assuring each diamond meets our high quality standards. When it comes to selecting loose diamonds for our inventory, we are—to put it candidly—extremely picky. To learn about all of our loose diamond standards, please visit us in-person at our store or reach out to schedule a virtual diamond presentation.


Only Natural Diamonds

We believe in providing our clients with jewelry and diamonds that hold value and can be considered an asset. For that reason, we are proud to offer our clients natural diamonds. We do not, and will not, sell lab grown diamonds. Here are a few reasons why we believe in only selling natural diamonds...


The value of natural diamonds comes from their uniqueness and rarity as a naturally occuring gem. According to Only Natural Diamonds, "The amount of natural diamonds 1 carat and larger recovered in a year would only fill one exercise ball." This rarity and finiteness make natural diamonds valuable. On average, natural diamonds retain inherent value appreciating in price by approximately 3% on average each year. On the other hand, lab grown diamonds can be replicated at unlimited quantities for pennies on the dollar to the wholesaling company.

upgrading, trading or selling

Because natural diamonds are rare and have intrinsic value, we will always allow our natural diamonds to be traded in (for a larger or better quality natural diamond) or sold back to us. We are a trustworthy source for both situations, offering our clients top-dollar for their natural diamonds. On the other hand, since lab grown diamonds do not hold value (especially since they're flooding the market with supply), it would be nearly impossible to sell your lab grown diamond at a fraction of the price you paid.

unique symbol of love

For centuries, diamonds have been a symbol of love. You gift the person you've fallen in love with a rare and unique natural diamond engagement ring. Like an individual's fingerprint, no two natural diamonds are identical.