• Established in 1979
  • Authorized dealer
  • Lifetime guarantee
  • Exceptional diamond prices
  • 0% Financing
  • Lifetime diamond upgrade
  • Free insured shipping



Trust Indiana’s diamond experts to give you the best payout. When you bring your diamond to Moyer Fine Jewelers, one of our on-staff GIA Graduate Gemologists will estimate the value of your diamond by weighing it, measuring it, and referring to any documentation or certification that came with your diamond. We will then give you an instant offer or purchase price, paying you immediately after you agree to the price. This is all done while you wait!

6 Reasons to Choose Moyer Fine Jewelers


When you are thinking of selling your diamond(s), think no further than Moyer Fine Jewelers. Located in Carmel, Indiana, we have been in the business of buying and selling diamonds for over 35 years. Here are a few compelling reasons to sell your diamond at Moyer

1. Experts on Hand

We have GIA certified experts on-staff. With care and quickness, they can clean, assess and quantify your diamond for a same-day offer. Our GIA experts know how to properly assess a diamond and diamond jewelry, giving proper attention to its proportions and its value.

2. Complete Communication

Our GIA experts will be happy to communicate how they came to the dollar assessment on your diamond. They will clearly explain how the price was determined and why your diamond might be worth more or less than you expect.

3. Industry Connections

Unlike some gold and diamond buyers, we work closely with wholesalers and national diamond buyers. Rather than selling to a discounter, we meet regularly with our long-standing vendors. They trust us to procure the best quality diamonds, and we, in turn, trust them for a fair and reasonable price which we can pass along to our client.

4. Quick Turn Around

Without highly trained staff, our on-site GIA gemologists, and our generous purchasing budget, we have the luxury of offering immediate appraised prices and instant payout. If we come to a fair agreement, you can leave with cash the very same day.

5. Fair Price

We pay top dollar for your diamonds and diamond jewelry. We are able to do this based on our long-standing reputation as a quality diamond buyer and reseller, and our ability to sell estate jewelry and gemstones, including diamond jewelry and loose diamonds.

6. Discretion

As a proud, family owned business with strong ties in the local community, we understand the need for discretion. We offer a professional, private transaction where you are comfortable with the price offered and the service given. It is always our goal to keep you as a long-standing customer.



We recommend an appointment for our diamond buying services, but an appointment is not required. We are fully staffed at all times with expert appraisers, GIA certified gemologists and trained jewelers. We would love to discuss your diamond selling options. We invite you to come into our store, located north of Indianapolis, Indiana and consult with one of our expert buyers about the sale of your diamond(s) and diamond jewelry.





Maximum upload image size: 2MB


We are available to answer any questions you may have about the process.

Call us at (317) 844-9003
Visit our Contact Us page

Our Company


The prices on the website may differ from the actual sale price. Please note that Moyer Fine Jewelers is not liable for incorrect pricing on the website.