• Established in 1979
  • Authorized dealer
  • Lifetime guarantee
  • Exceptional diamond prices
  • 0% Financing
  • Lifetime diamond upgrade
  • Free insured shipping

We Buy Jewelry & Watches


  • We pay more
  • Guaranteed pricing
  • Expert evaluation
  • Your needs are respected
  • Additional 20% applied immediately towards a store credit or trade





Bring your diamonds, gold or other jewelry items to Moyer Fine Jewelers to have them evaluated by a certified jewelry appraiser who will carefully assess each of your pieces to provide the most accurate value. We will make you the highest offer possible. Our store is welcoming and professional, and you’ll be treated with the value and respect you deserve.





Maximum upload image size: 2MB

Sell your jewelry & get cash today!

There are many places to sell your jewelry, but we can guarantee Moyer Fine Jewelers is the first place you'll want to stop. Established in Indianapolis for 35 years, the Moyer name is synonymous with quality, designer jewelry and exceptional customer service.

In addition to building strong relationships with our customers, we also have cultivated a longstanding, trustworthy relationship with gold and diamond buyers. They look to us for quality precious metals and gemstones; 14k gold, platinum, white gold, including parts and findings, as well as diamonds and precious gemstones. We are able to receive top dollar figures on our gold and diamond buys, due to our volume, our history, and our stellar reputation.

Even though we have a wonderful relationship with our diamond and gold buyer, we are also able to display and sell estate and resale items within our flagship jewelry store. Many of our regular customers appreciate a unique jewelry piece or a rarely discounted designer piece offered as a resale. Many times, we are able to clean, repair, and upgrade a resale piece, and then display it in our estate jewelry section. This option allows us to offer the best purchase price to you.


What Determines Your Diamond’s Worth?

  • ● The shape and size of your diamond
  • ● The color and clarity of your diamond
  • ● The cut of your diamond
  • ● The marketability and desirability ofyour diamond

What Makes Your Gold Valuable?

  • ● The karat content of your jewelry
  • ● The more pure, the higher the value
  • ● The market price (oz/gold)
  • ● The weight of the piece you are selling

Our Company


The prices on the website may differ from the actual sale price. Please note that Moyer Fine Jewelers is not liable for incorrect pricing on the website.